Getting an MBA is not the right decision for everyone. A Forbes opinion piece a while back gave a thumbs down to the MBA route. And it made some valid points. The true key to success is indeed mastering the process of idea and solution discovery. And if you can figure that out to the degrees necessary for your success, then maybe you should save the $150k!
Of course, though, there’s more to it than that. For one thing, we shouldn’t soft pedal the number of people who have experienced the highly structured learning environment of an elite MBA program as exactly the milieu for mastering just such skills. That though isn’t the only matter that has to be weighed in taking the measure of such criticism.
Here are a few questions you might ask yourself.
Even if you put no value at all on the academics, where else are you going to get exposure to this kind of a network? At the top schools, the best in the business will come in as guest speakers. And socializing opportunities are never missed. Plus, among your own classmates, you’ll find many of the hot up and comers.
Making these great connections while you’re all still climbing up the industry latter will great a camaraderie that will serve you a lifetime. (Though, this does require, as we’ve emphasized elsewhere, choosing the right program for your chosen industry). And don’t forget too the special perk of an MBA: a strong, influential alumni association.
Another perk you might not have fully thought through is the blank slate effect? You do kind of become a fresh new opportunity. This isn’t to say that after an MBA your past experience is irrelevant. Of course not. What’s different is that you are no longer limited by it. When some potential new employer regards you, freshly graduated from an MBA, what they see is no longer defined by your past.
Your past work history is no longer evaluated as a summary of your future potential. Now, your past work experience merely supplements your value as a prospective new colleague. But now you have the additional virtue of having demonstrated the initiative and exercised the discipline to better yourself; to in fact have equipped yourself with an exciting new skill set, body of knowledge and valuable professional connections. You’re now full of the promise of new opportunities.
What about the benefits of challenging your comfort zone? It’s all nice and good to talk about getting out there and mastering the discovery of new ideas and so on. But what does that really mean? How do you actually start doing that? An MBA is a deliberate decision on your part to remove yourself from your established routine and place yourself in an environment designed to challenge you.
You carve from your busy life the time to concentrate on personal improvement and advance. And you place yourself in a situation which will demand the best of you. If you can do that all on your own, that’s excellent. But how many people fool themselves that they are (or will, someday soon) do so? When you take the leap and enrol in an MBA program, there’s no fooling anyone. You’ve taken the challenge and have to rise to your best to succeed.
It’s probably true that a lot of money and time is wasted on MBA pursuits that might have been better left unfulfilled. However, even aside of the curriculum there are many subtle, though extremely beneficial, perks of an MBA which it would be a mistake to underestimate. These are some the questions you should be asking yourself to be sure that it’s the right choice for you.
Thomas Ryerson write regularly for the site, Business Week MBA Rankings, check it out here.
